Articles Cross Platform Text-to-Speech by Erik van Bilsen

[emailx45]

Cross Platform Text-to-Speech
January 9, 2017 Erik van Bilsen

Спойлер: Content - 1st part

[SHOWTOGROUPS=4,20]
This post is a small exercise in designing a cross platform abstraction layer for platform-specific functionality. In particular, we present a small Delphi library to add cross platform text-to-speech to your app. It works on Windows, macOS, iOS and Android.

You can find the Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся on GitHub as part of the Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся repository.

If you are only interested in the end result, then you can stick to the first part of this post and bail when we get to the implementation details.

Choosing a feature set
A common issue with abstracting platform differences is that you must decide on a feature set. A specific feature may be supported on one platform, but not on another. When it comes to text-to-speech, some platforms support choosing a voice, changing the pitch or speech rate, customize pronunciation with markup in the text to speak etc. Other platforms may not support some of these features, or only in an incompatible way.

You can choose to go for the lowest common denominator approach and only expose those features that are supported on all platforms. Or you can choose to support more features which either do nothing on certain platforms or raise some kind of “not supported” exception. Or you can have a combination of both.

Also, there may be some features (or issues) on one platform that also affect the API for other platforms. For example, on all platforms except Android, you can start speaking immediately after you create the text-to-speech engine. On Android though, you have to wait until the engine has fully initialized in the background before you can use it. This means that we have to add some sort of notification to the engine to let clients know that the engine has initialized. On non-Android platforms, we just fire this event immediately after construction.

To keep the size of this post somewhat manageable, we only support the most basic text-to-speech features: speaking some text (using the default voice and settings) and stopping it. At the end of this post, you should be able to add other features yourself.

IgoTextToSpeech API
In our blog post about Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся we presented different ways to abstract platform-specific API differences. For the text-to-speech library we use the “object interface” approach as discussed in that post. The text-to-speech API is defined in an interface called IgoTextToSpeech (in the unit Grijjy.TextToSpeech):

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

type IgoTextToSpeech = interface ['{7797ED2A-0695-445A-BA84-495E280F86AB}'] {$REGION 'Internal Declarations'} function _GetAvailable: Boolean; function _GetOnAvailable: TNotifyEvent; ..etc... {$ENDREGION 'Internal Declarations'} function Speak(const AText: String): Boolean; procedure Stop; function IsSpeaking: Boolean; property Available: Boolean read _GetAvailable; property OnAvailable: TNotifyEvent read _GetOnAvailable write _SetOnAvailable; property OnSpeechStarted: TNotifyEvent read _GetOnSpeechStarted write _SetOnSpeechStarted; property OnSpeechFinished: TNotifyEvent read _GetOnSpeechFinished write _SetOnSpeechFinished; end;

To speak some text, just call the Speak method and supply the text to speak. If the engine was already speaking some text, then the current speech will be terminated. This method is asynchronous and returns immediately while the text is spoken in the background. Once the engine actually starts to speak, it will fire the OnSpeechStarted event.

You can use Stop to stop speaking. Depending on the platform, this will stop speaking immediately or wait until the current word has been finished. The OnSpeechFinished event will be fired when the speech has stopped, either because there is no more text to speak, or you called Stop to terminate the speech.

Finally, you will note the Available property and OnAvailable event. As said above, on all platforms except Android, the speech engine will be available immediately. The Available property will be True and OnAvailable will be fired immediately after creating the engine.

On Android however, it takes time to initialize the engine and it may not be available immediately. You have to wait until the engine has fully initialized (by checking the Available property), or you can use the OnAvailable event to get notified when this happens.

In all cases, it is probably easiest and safest to always use the OnAvailable event (on all platforms) and don’t speak any text until this event has been fired.

You may have noticed that I started the names of all property/event getter and setter methods with an underscore (like _GetAvailable). This is to persuade the user of the interface to use the property/event instead of calling the method directly. These methods won’t even show up in Code Insight if you prefix them with an underscore (although you can still call them if you insist).

You create an object that implements this interface by simply calling:

1	TextToSpeech := TgoTextToSpeech.Create;

This uses the static class function approach to create the platform-specific instance, as discussed in the Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся post.
All in all not too complicated. Try out the Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся in the repository to see how it works on all platforms.

Super Simple Text-to-Speech

The remainder of this post discusses how text-to-speech is implemented on the various platforms. Feel free to skip this if you don’t care about the details. However, if you are new to COM or using (and defining) Java classes and Objective-C classes, and want to learn a bit about it, then stick around.

TgoTextToSpeechBase class
A base implementation of the IgoTextToSpeech interface is provided in the abstract TgoTextToSpeechBase class. This class provides the fields for the Available property and the various events, as well as helper methods to fire the events from the main thread (so you can update the UI from those events if you want to).
The actual API methods (Speak, Stop and IsSpeaking) are all virtual and abstract and overridden by the platform-specific derived classes.

Text-to-Speech on Windows
On Windows, we use the Speech API to provide text-to-speech. This API is built using the Component Object Model (COM). Unfortunately, Delphi does not provide the translations of the Speech API header files. However, it is pretty easy to import them as a type library:

1. In Delphi, pick the “Component | Import Component…” menu option.
2. Select “Import a Type Library”.
3. The next page shows all registered type libraries. There should be a “Microsoft Speech Object Library” in there.
4. You can finish the wizard and create an import unit.

Import the Speech API Type Library

Unfortunately the type library importer imports some declarations incorrectly, which can be especially problematic when used inside a 64-bit Windows app. So instead, I extracted the declarations we care about from the imported type library, fixed them and put them at the top of the Grijjy.TextToSpeech.Windows unit.

The main COM object for text-to-speech is exposed through the ISpVoice interface. You create this COM object with the following code:

1	FVoice := CreateComObject(CLASS_SpVoice) as ISpVoice;

Then we can speak some text using its Speak method:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

function TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Speak(const AText: String): Boolean; begin if (FVoice = nil) then Result := False else Result := (FVoice.Speak(PWideChar(AText), SPF_ASYNC, nil) = S_OK); end;

We pass the SPF_ASYNC flag so the method returns immediately and speaks the text in the background.

If we want to get notified when the system has finished speaking, then we need to subscribe to an event. We need to let the engine know which events we are interested in (through the SetInterest method) and how we should get notified (by calling the SetNotifyCallbackFunction method):

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

constructor TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Create; var Events: ULONGLONG; begin inherited Create; FVoice := CreateComObject(CLASS_SpVoice) as ISpVoice; if (FVoice <> nil) then begin Events := SPFEI(SPEI_START_INPUT_STREAM) or SPFEI(SPEI_END_INPUT_STREAM); OleCheck(FVoice.SetInterest(Events, Events)); OleCheck(FVoice.SetNotifyCallbackFunction(VoiceCallback, 0, NativeInt(Self))); end; end;

Note that SetInterest and SetNotifyCallbackFunction methods are not defined in ISpVoice. They are declared in parent interfaces of ISpVoice, called ISpEventSource and ISpNotifySource respectively.

Here we say we are interested in when the system starts and stops speaking (see the Events variable). We pass this variable twice to the SetInterest method. The first one is to tell the system what events we are interested in. The second one (which must be the same as or a subset of the first one) tells the system what events should be queued in the event queue. We need to enable this queuing because it is the only way to know what event has been fired.

The actual notification occurs by calling the function that is passed to the SetNotifyCallbackFunction method. This must be a stdcall function with the following signature:

1 2 3 4 5

class procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.VoiceCallback( wParam: WPARAM; lParam: LPARAM); begin TgoTextToSpeechImplementation(lParam).HandleVoiceEvent; end;

Note that there are other ways to be notified than using a callback function. For example, you can also have the engine send a Window Message, or you can create a “notification sink” by implementing the ISpNotifySink interface.

You can declare the callback as a global function, or you can make it a static class method. We choose the second approach here to keep things organized.

The callback receives two parameters, which are the same parameters as passed to the SetNotifyCallbackFunction API. We passed Self as the second parameter there so that we can access our object from the (global) callback function (as lParam). Here, the callback just forwards the notification to the HandleVoiceEvent method of our class:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.HandleVoiceEvent; var Event: SPEVENT; NumEvents: ULONG; begin if (FVoice = nil) then Exit; { Handle all events in the event queue. Before calling GetEvents, the Event record should be cleared. } FillChar(Event, SizeOf(Event), 0); while (FVoice.GetEvents(1, @Event, NumEvents) = S_OK) do begin case Event.eEventId of SPEI_START_INPUT_STREAM: DoSpeechStarted; SPEI_END_INPUT_STREAM: DoSpeechFinished; end; FillChar(Event, SizeOf(Event), 0); end; end;

This method just processes the event queue for start and finish notifications and fires the OnSpeechStarted and OnSpeechFinished events accordingly.

That covers the most important concepts on the Windows side.


[/SHOWTOGROUPS]

 

[emailx45]

Спойлер: Content - 2nd part

[SHOWTOGROUPS=4,20]
Text-to-Speech on macOS
On macOS, you will use the Objective-C (or Swift) class NSSpeechSynthesizer, which is declared in the unit Macapi.AppKit. This is a bit easier than creating a COM object on Windows:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

constructor TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Create; begin inherited Create; FSpeechSynthesizer := TNSSpeechSynthesizer.Create; end; destructor TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Destroy; begin if (FSpeechSynthesizer <> nil) then FSpeechSynthesizer.release; inherited; end;

Since we are creating a new instance here, we need to release it in the destructor.

Speaking some text is trivial:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

function TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Speak(const AText: String): Boolean; begin if (FSpeechSynthesizer = nil) then Result := False else Result := FSpeechSynthesizer.startSpeakingString(StrToNSStr(AText)); end;

It just converts a Delphi string to a NSString and passes it to the startSpeakingString method.

Notifications work a bit different on macOS (and iOS). If you want to get notified about certain events (like when the engine has finished speaking), then you need to implement a delegate and assign it to the speech synthesizer.

The delegate you need to implement is called NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegate. Delphi choose not to provide translations for the methods in this delegate, so we have to do that ourselves. We can do so by deriving an interface from NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegate and add the notification methods we are interested in:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

type NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegateEx = interface(NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegate) ['{D0AE9338-9D9B-4857-A404-255F40E4EB09}'] [MethodName('speechSynthesizer:willSpeakPhoneme:')] procedure speechSynthesizerWillSpeakPhoneme(sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; phonemeOpcode: Smallint); cdecl; [MethodName('speechSynthesizer:didFinishSpeaking:')] procedure speechSynthesizerDidFinishSpeaking(sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; finishedSpeaking: Boolean); cdecl; end;

The delegate contains more methods than these, but these are the only ones we are interested in. (In Objective-C, delegates are protocols and often its methods are optional, so you only need to implement those you care about).

You may note the MethodName attributes above. These are needed here because of the way Objective-C methods are named. In Objective-C, a method name includes the names of its parameters (after the first one). Usually, when these are translated to Delphi, we only translate the first part of the Objective-C method name to a Delphi method name, and make sure that the names of the parameters match those on the Objective-C side. That way, Delphi can link the Delphi method to the corresponding Objective-C method. In this case however, both methods start with the same text (speechSynthesizer), so we use the MethodName attribute to let Delphi now what the full name of the method is so it link it to the correct method.

Now, we need to implement this delegate inside a Delphi class. We do this by creating a class derived from TOCLocal and implement the delegate interface. In this case, we need to list both the NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegate and NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegateEx interfaces. In the sample code, the delegate is implemented in a private nested class:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

type TgoTextToSpeechImplementation = class(TgoTextToSpeechBase) {$REGION 'Internal Declarations'} private type TDelegate = class(TOCLocal, NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegate, NSSpeechSynthesizerDelegateEx) private FTextToSpeech: TgoTextToSpeechImplementation; FStartedSpeaking: Boolean; public constructor Create(const ATextToSpeech: TgoTextToSpeechImplementation); public { AVSpeechSynthesizerDelegate } [MethodName('speechSynthesizer:willSpeakPhoneme:')] procedure speechSynthesizerWillSpeakPhoneme(sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; phonemeOpcode: Smallint); cdecl; [MethodName('speechSynthesizer:didFinishSpeaking:')] procedure speechSynthesizerDidFinishSpeaking(sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; finishedSpeaking: Boolean); cdecl; end; public ...etc... end;

We create and assign the delegate as follows:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

constructor TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Create; begin inherited Create; FSpeechSynthesizer := TNSSpeechSynthesizer.Create; if (FSpeechSynthesizer <> nil) then begin FDelegate := TDelegate.Create(Self); FSpeechSynthesizer.setDelegate(FDelegate); Available := True; end; end;

The implementation of the delegate is fairly simple:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

constructor TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.TDelegate.Create( const ATextToSpeech: TgoTextToSpeechImplementation); begin inherited Create; FTextToSpeech := ATextToSpeech; end; procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.TDelegate.speechSynthesizerDidFinishSpeaking( sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; finishedSpeaking: Boolean); begin FStartedSpeaking := False; if Assigned(FTextToSpeech) then FTextToSpeech.DoSpeechFinished; end; procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.TDelegate.speechSynthesizerWillSpeakPhoneme( sender: NSSpeechSynthesizer; phonemeOpcode: Smallint); begin if (not FStartedSpeaking) then begin FStartedSpeaking := True; if Assigned(FTextToSpeech) then FTextToSpeech.DoSpeechStarted; end; end;

The only caveat here is that the speechSynthesizerWillSpeakPhoneme method is called multiple times per sentence, and we only want to send the OnSpeechStarted event once. We take care of this with an extra Boolean flag.

That’s it for macOS.

Text-to-Speech on iOS
You would expect that the iOS version would be very similar to the macOS version. To some degree it is. For example, you create a speech synthesizer (of type AVSpeechSynthesizer this time) and implement a delegate (AVSpeechSynthesizerDelegate).

Delphi does not provide imports for these classes, so we imported them ourselves and added them to the top of the Grijjy.TextToSpeech.iOS unit.

But that is where the similarities end. To speak some text, you need to create a speech utterance and pass it to the synthesizer. Also, in contrast to macOS, you need to explicitly stop any current speech before you start some new speech. Otherwise, the new speech will be queued:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

function TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Speak(const AText: String): Boolean; var Utterance: AVSpeechUtterance; begin if (FSpeechSynthesizer.isSpeaking) then FSpeechSynthesizer.stopSpeakingAtBoundary(AVSpeechBoundaryImmediate); Utterance := TAVSpeechUtterance.OCClass.speechUtteranceWithString(StrToNSStr(AText)); if (not TOSVersion.Check(9)) then Utterance.setRate(DEFAULT_SPEECH_RATE_IOS8_DOWN); FSpeechSynthesizer.speakUtterance(Utterance); Result := True; end;

You’ll also note some version specific code in there. An AVSpeechUtterance has a (speech) Rate property, that ranges from 0.0 to 1.0. The default 0.5 is supposed to represent a “normal” speech rate. Lower values slow down the speech and higher values speed it up. However, on iOS 8 and earlier the default of 0.5 is way too fast and we have to lower the value to about 0.1 to make it comparable to the default on iOS 9 and later. Don’t you just love these version-specific idiosyncrasies!
Other than that, the code is similar to the macOS version.

Text-to-Speech on Android
Finally, we consider the Android side of things. It’s not too different from the macOS/iOS version. Instead of an Objective-C class we have a Java class here called TextToSpeech (which is implemented in Delphi through the JTextToSpeech interface).

And instead of a delegate, we implement a listener to get notified when speech has completed. This listener is a nested interface of the TextToSpeech class called OnUtteranceCompletedListener. Because it is a nested type, it is translated to Delphi using the fully qualified name JTextToSpeech_OnUtteranceCompletedListener.

Note that the JTextToSpeech and related interfaces are only available in Delphi 10.1 Berlin (and later). For earlier versions of Delphi, you would have to import this interfaces yourself, preferably using Для просмотра ссылки Войди или Зарегистрируйся. We did this for you and added the interfaces we care about to the top of the Grijjy.TextToSpeech.Android unit.

But as you may remember from the beginning of this article, the engine works a bit differently on Android: the engine will not be immediately available. When you create a JTextToSpeech class on Android, you need to pass (another) listener that gets called when the engine has finished initialization. On the Delphi side, this means that you need to implement the JTextToSpeech_OnInitListener interface. You do that by deriving a class from TJavaLocal and implement the interface. We choose to do this in a nested type again:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

type TgoTextToSpeechImplementation = class(TgoTextToSpeechBase) private type TInitListener = class(TJavaLocal, JTextToSpeech_OnInitListener) private [weak] FImplementation: TgoTextToSpeechImplementation; public { JTextToSpeech_OnInitListener } procedure onInit(status: Integer); cdecl; public constructor Create(const AImplementation: TgoTextToSpeechImplementation); end; private FTextToSpeech: JTextToSpeech; FInitListener: TInitListener; public ...etc... end;

You’ll notice that in the listener class, I made the reference to the outer implementation class a [weak] reference. This is needed because the implementation class references the listener, and the listener class references the implementation class. Without this [weak] reference we would have a reference cycle and a memory leak. We have the same issue in the iOS version, but I sort of skipped over that detail in the discussion.

The listener just forwards the notification to the implementation class:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.TInitListener.onInit(status: Integer); begin if Assigned(FImplementation) then FImplementation.Initialize(status); end; procedure TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Initialize(const AStatus: Integer); begin FInitListener := nil; if (AStatus = TJTextToSpeech.JavaClass.SUCCESS) then begin Available := True; DoAvailable; FTextToSpeech.setLanguage(TJLocale.JavaClass.getDefault); { We need a hash map with a KEY_PARAM_UTTERANCE_ID parameter. Otherwise, onUtteranceCompleted will not get called. } FParams := TJHashMap.Create; FParams.put(TJTextToSpeech_Engine.JavaClass.KEY_PARAM_UTTERANCE_ID, StringToJString('DummyUtteranceId')); FCompletedListener := TCompletedListener.Create(Self); FTextToSpeech.setOnUtteranceCompletedListener(FCompletedListener); end else FTextToSpeech := nil; end;

Here we release the listener (by assigning nil) because we don’t need it anymore. If the engine was successfully initialized, we fire the OnAvailable event and further customize our engine. In particular:

• We create a (Java) hash map with a single item containing a (dummy) identifier for speech utterances. We pass this hash map later to the speak method. The only reason we do this is because the system will not send a “utterance completed” notification without this.
• We implement and create an “utterance completed” listener and assign it to the JTextToSpeech object. The implementation of this listener is trivial and not shown here.

Then we can finally speak some text:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

function TgoTextToSpeechImplementation.Speak(const AText: String): Boolean; begin if Assigned(FTextToSpeech) then begin Result := (FTextToSpeech.speak(StringToJString(AText), TJTextToSpeech.JavaClass.QUEUE_FLUSH, FParams) = TJTextToSpeech.JavaClass.SUCCESS); if (Result) then DoSpeechStarted; end else Result := False; end;

We pass the hash map we created before, as well as a QUEUE_FLUSH flag that is used to tell the engine to terminate any current speech.

[/SHOWTOGROUPS]